Flat rate shipping when you spend $75 or more! Our retail location is temporarily closed. Curb-side pick-up Mon-Sat 12-5.

Collection: Mystery

24 products
  • Foul Play & Cabernet 1000pc Mystery Puzzle
    Vendor
    Bepuzzled
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Original #30: Strictly Can't Dance! 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Murder on the Nile 1000pc Mystery Puzzle
    Vendor
    Bepuzzled
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Mystery Retro #4: Live Entertainment! 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Mystery Puzzle: Murder in Little Piddling 1000pc Large Format Puzzle
    Vendor
    White Mountain
    Regular price
    $23.99
    Sale price
    $23.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Alfred Hitchcock 1000pc Mystery Puzzle
    Vendor
    Bepuzzled
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Original #32: The Big Weigh In! 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Mystery #19: Bingo Blunder! 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Destiny Retro #4: The Wasgij Games! 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • The Sting of APEP 1000pc Mystery Puzzle
    Vendor
    White Mountain
    Regular price
    $23.99
    Sale price
    $23.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Grounds for Murder: A Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Bepuzzled
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Mystery #18: Grabbing a Quick Bite! 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Original #33: Calm on the Canal! 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Destiny #21: Highway Holdup 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Enigmatic Puzzles: Antique Attic 500pc Mystery Puzzle
    Vendor
    Educa
    Regular price
    $19.99
    Sale price
    $19.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Sherlock Holmes and the Speckled Band 1000pc Mystery Puzzle
    Vendor
    Bepuzzled
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Escape Puzzle: The Curse of the Wolves 756pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Ravensburger
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Original #31: Safari Surprise 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • F is for Feline 2x500pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    TDC Puzzles
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • B is for Birthday 2x500pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    TDC Puzzles
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Wasgij Mystery #17: Catching a Break! 1000pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    Jumbo
    Regular price
    $29.99
    Sale price
    $29.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Enigmatic Puzzles: Old Library 500pc Mystery Puzzle
    Vendor
    Educa
    Regular price
    $19.99
    Sale price
    $19.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • Enigmatic Puzzles: Train Puzzle 500pc Mystery Puzzle
    Vendor
    Educa
    Regular price
    $19.99
    Sale price
    $19.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock
  • C is for Chocolate 2x500pc Puzzle
    Vendor
    TDC Puzzles
    Regular price
    $24.99
    Sale price
    $24.99
    Regular price
    Unit price
    per 
    Out of Stock